Starman Awards

[Hoover Attack]

Blimey. Some funny decisions - nothing for Omar or Currie - but this is bizarre.

[Proposition Joe]

Bizarre award to have, full stop.

[Hoover Attack]

It’s like a SuperFan award, I guess.

[Scuba Diver]

Super fans that don’t look at the team sheet to see if ‘Danny’ is actually playing..

[Hoover Attack]

Donley has been outstanding in the last few weeks, very good earlier in 2025, average in December 2024 and a calamity for the first 4 months of the season. Giving him Player of the Season ahead of Galbraith, Omar, Currie and Kelman is the football equivalent of a judge giving the points to the boxer who starts throwing windmills for the last 15 seconds of a round.

[PKM]

That Currie doesn’t get an award is a travesty
Could we have a MB whip round or something and award Jack
‘Outstanding full back of the season ‘ award or something similar

[Hoover Attack]

Galbraith has been pretty decent playing as an inverted right back. Would need to make it either best LB or best traditional full back.

[Hoover Attack]

Same as both 2019 and 2023, lots of genuine contenders for the top prize. It's almost as if you need several players to perform well to be successful.

[PKM]

Galbraith has been pretty decent playing as an inverted right back. Would need to make it either best LB or best traditional full back.

Good point

[Proposition Joe]

Donley has been outstanding in the last few weeks, very good earlier in 2025, average in December 2024 and a calamity for the first 4 months of the season. Giving him Player of the Season ahead of Galbraith, Omar, Currie and Kelman is the football equivalent of a judge giving the points to the boxer who starts throwing windmills for the last 15 seconds of a round.

Calamity is an exaggeration but absolutely no way is he our PotS, any of the 4 you mention - and probably even Keeley - all far and away more consistent over the past 9 months. Madness and based on that one goal (which wasn't even his).

[gshaw]

That Currie doesn’t get an award is a travesty
Could we have a MB whip round or something and award Jack
‘Outstanding full back of the season ‘ award or something similar

The James Milner award for quiet consistency. He's there week in week out giving you a 7/10 or above every game, been a great signing.

[PKM]

Donley has been outstanding in the last few weeks, very good earlier in 2025, average in December 2024 and a calamity for the first 4 months of the season. Giving him Player of the Season ahead of Galbraith, Omar, Currie and Kelman is the football equivalent of a judge giving the points to the boxer who starts throwing windmills for the last 15 seconds of a round.

Calamity is an exaggeration but absolutely no way is he our PotS, any of the 4 you mention - and probably even Keeley - all far and away more consistent over the past 9 months. Madness and based on that one goal (which wasn't even his).

With 10 assists and 8 goals hardly based on that one goal. Not to mention he’s all round play. He had a slow start, but has developed into an outstanding player. I agree probably not POTS but he’s certainly up there.