Seasons Ratings

[gshaw]

Turley - 6 - Probably a bit controversial, dont really see the fascination. He did a job when he came in but would be too sad if he didn't re sign.

I guess you're judging him purely on technical footballing ability, in that area I could see your point. However he's vital for a bit of pure cynical filth against sides that want to try kick us off the park.

Forget which game but we were caught on a counter and Turley had no hesitation in taking the attacker out, no intention to play the ball. We need that as too often "nice" Orient wouldn't do that. Also like how he gets niggly with the opposition, laughing in their faces and just generally being a nuisance.

Would retain him in the Whing / Cuthbert role for the physical games. If we want to keep playing 3-5-2 we need more CBs to cover.

[F*ck The Poor & Fat]

Turley - 6 - Probably a bit controversial, dont really see the fascination. He did a job when he came in but would be too sad if he didn't re sign.

I guess you're judging him purely on technical footballing ability, in that area I could see your point. However he's vital for a bit of pure cynical filth against sides that want to try kick us off the park.

Forget which game but we were caught on a counter and Turley had no hesitation in taking the attacker out, no intention to play the ball. We need that as too often "nice" Orient wouldn't do that. Also like how he gets niggly with the opposition, laughing in their faces and just generally being a nuisance.

Would retain him in the Whing / Cuthbert role for the physical games. If we want to keep playing 3-5-2 we need more CBs to cover.

Agree. Nice to have players who can compete physically when needed. And he can. Hoped Alabi would provide that steel, but never did.

[ComeOnYouOs]

Ill go with:

Brill - 8 - Had my doubts about him this season but cant really complain about his clean sheets. His weak spot is coming out for crosses and getting down quickly but he has made some stunning saves and his influence and leadership has definitely helped our defenders.

Widdowson - 7 - Pretty steady and an improvement on last year. Started the season really well but been under par in the last few months. As much as he is clearly a grafter, i think we will need to upgrade next season and have Joe as a backup LB/CB.

Ling - 5 - He looked lost in the first few games and didn't really improve on that. I liked what i saw last season but I dont think he can defend unfortunately.

Judd - 6 - He had some really great performances. I love his intensity and determination and probably our best full back in an attacking sense but he cant stay fit. If he could it would be a 7 or 8.

Coulson - 9 - The guy is immense. Scored some valuable goals and a real leader at the back. Dont think he had a really bad game all season. Also helped the young CBs

Ekpiteta - 8 - Considering it was his first full season in the NL, he did so well. He has such quick feet for a gangly CB and his positional sense is spot on. Really impressed with him this year and only disappointing thing was that it took big George getting injured for him to get a shot.

Happe - 7 - Really calm and cultured CB and still so young. Had a few times where he looked a bit lost and not quiet at Marvs level yet but could surpass him next year.

Turley - 6 - Probably a bit controversial, dont really see the fascination. He did a job when he came in but would be too sad if he didn't re sign.

Maguire-Drew - 6 - Showed some good signs and i think he is one for the future. Still very young and a clever player. Not fit enough when he came in probably. Excited to see him next year.

Brophy - 7 - A tale of two halves really. Started off the season pretty poorly and i dont think he's been fit until the last 6 weeks. Undoubtably though, he is the quickest player in the team and can be a spark to make things happen. MUST work on his decision making and final ball but he took one for the team more than once and played in about 5 positions in the run in.

Dayton - 5 - Just didn't happen for him this year. Came back from injury last year and never looked the same. Didn't want to take people on and looked sluggish. Loved him last year but think his time should be up with us.

McAnuff - 9 - Performance wise, the season caught up with him fast. He was unreal in the first few months but his age obviously became a factor as the pitches got heavier and the weather got worse. But saying that, his influence seems to be irrespective of his performances. He is a leader and a calming presence on the pitch and whilst i was dubious about bringing him back, i dont think we get promoted without him.

Lee - 5 - Struggled the whole season. Looks to have lost a few yards of pace after his injury and apart from a spell of about 4 games, barely had an influence on any games. Gotta be released.

Lawless - 5.5 - Hard to judge as he didn't get many chances. Was one of our best players in the first game of the season but then fell out of favour. Didn't really do much in his rare appearances. Release.

Gorman - 4 - Probably not all his fault but got about 45 mins of pre-season and never caught up with everyone else. Still think theres a player in there and he is only 21 so i have hope for next year, in a better league, he will have a bit more space and thrive. But based on this year, he was a key player we really needed to be good and he didn't have one good game all year.

Clay - 8 - Its easy to forget that he was pretty bad at the start of the season. But his second half has been key. He has single handedly held the midfield together in some games and his fitness is probably the best in the league. Deserves a new contract next year.

Koroma - 8 - Clearly too good for the NL in his general play, decision making needs improvement but i wouldn't want to take away his confidence when shooting from everywhere. its lead to seem class goals and he will surely win goal of the season for the bromley one. Its been a pleasure watching him come on this year and improve every week. Hope we can keep him.

Bonne - 9 - Without his goals we finish about 10th. Struggled in the latter part of the season with goals but his effort is always 100% and brings so much to the team. His determination is something to behold and he played literally every league game and almost every minute. Hopefully we get some players in to be able to give him rest and help with his scoring in the latter half of seasons.

Harrold - 6 - Struggled to start the season and didn't really do anything in-between multiple injuries but after xmas he has been huge. Our only player who can win a ball and chipped in with a couple of goals. Personally think we can do better but will be interesting if he gets a new contract.

Alabi - 2 - Such a disappointment. Was brought in to be Bonne's partner and failed miserably. Scored 2 goals all year, 2! Ran around a lot like a headless chicken but hasn't got the quality. need to somehow ship him out. sorry.

Simpson - 4 - Disappointing. Scored one goal and looked good in one game but in hindsight, was probably a poor decision to bring him in instead of another midfielder. Doubt he'll be back.

These ratings are far more accurate than the opening posts ( IMO of course)

[ComeOnYouOs]

Couldn't be bothered contributing to the Braintree rating because as we all know we are champions because what we have done over the whole season. Seven defeats, the 3rd highest number of goals and the best defence (fact). My ratings for the season (current squad only(:

Brill - 7.5 - a guy who came to us as a coach and prior to Edinburgh coming in hadn't played a competitive match for 2.5 years (little known fact, his first game for the O's was also Edinburgh's first game). Very few mistakes, command his box in the air (most of the time) and pulled off some world class saves this season. I can live with him still being a bit chunky!

Sam Ling - 6 - Has had a stop-start season but, for me, not as strong as Judd in the RB position. Looked more comfortable with the new formation but still a poor crosser of the ball

Joe Widdowson - 7 - I'm a big fan and like Clay his consistency has shone through this season. Needs a new contract. Just hate it when I see a player bombing through on the left or lurking at the back post and realise it is him. He will never ever score another goal in professional football

Myles Judd - 7 - Also a big fan. Yes he's rash but he is 19 and, given the chance by Edinburgh, will turn into our No1 RB/WB. I can see him thriving in the current formation

Josh Coulson - 8 - Would love to see him finish his career with us. Orient through and through, a rock at the back and his goals this season have been so important. The four games he missed after the Salford defeat we picked up four points - nuff said

Dan Happe - 7 - improving all the time and his season didn't start until he came off the bench at Salford for Coulson. Lacks pace and needs to be more aware of what is going on around him but he is only 20 and has earned his place.

Marvin Ekpiteta - 7.5 - Ridiculous improvement in such a short time. He was actually an unused sub for our first game of the season (Elokobi was picked ahead of him). Missed the same four games as Coulson after Salford and how we missed them both. I also don't think McCallum would have had is as easy as he did if Ekpiteta wasn't suspended. Bolster our midfield and we have a hell of a central team behind them next season.

Jamie Turley - 6 - Has done the job(s) we've asked him to do and we all know he is a bog standard old fashioned centre back who leaves his mark. Hard to see him being kept on

Alex Lawless - 6 - Was given a handful of starts after Edinburgh arrived but has never really featured since (only 7 league starts this season). In an average midfield wasn't able to command a place. Another who won't be here next season

Jobie McAnuff - 7.5 - A real captain (the look on his face as he was forced off today) and would love him to give us another season. His experience and intelligence really will be missed when he hangs up his boots.

Craig Clay - 7.5 - For chunks of this season he has been our only central midfielder, driving forward, last ditch tackles. Has become our most consistent player. He ain't half racking up the yellow cards though.

Jordan Maguire-Drew - 7 - looking forward to seeing this guy in action next season. Already looks like our best crosser of the ball and is naturally two-footed.

James Dayton - 6.5 - Can't make up my mind about him and another player whose season was ruined by injury. Only two assists this season where you would expect more. Always worked hard and will always look less spectacular than JMD and Koroma. Sentiment says offer him a year contract as a squad player.

James Brophy - 7 - Can be our most frustrating/exciting player (dead-heat with Koromoa). Had a difficult start to the season which didn't really happen until December. I think Edinburgh trusts him to put in a shift these days.

Dale Gorman - 5.5 - Think we expected too much of him but he has been our biggest disappointment. Admittedly didn't have a pre-season but his passing has to be better if he wants to be more than a squad player.

Charlie Lee - 6 - looks to be coming toward the end of his career. Clay carried him most of the time and his passing towards the end of the season was shocking. Surprised if he is with us next season

Macauley Bonne - 7,5 - 45 goals in 88 starts with some of the easiest misses I've ever seen thrown in. Runs all day and is brilliant at holding the ball up. Would hate to lose him and he can go out every Sunday, I don't mind.

Matt Harrold - 7 - has become our lucky mascot. I've been harsh in the past (once called him a piece of stone). Has only actually started 3 league games this season but his goals have been so important, especially the equaliser against Halifax and the one that finished Harrogate off. I recall his assist for Dayton's goal away at Chesterfield in a game when we were second best all game. Turns 35 in July and his cameo today was probably also his swansong. Thanks big guy

Josh Koromoa - 7.5. - For me a season of two halves. Was brilliant before his January injury and was capable of anything (watch his first at Fylde again). Since then he hasn't been the same play (brilliant goal against Halifax, mind). Will have a hell of a next season

James Alabi - 5 - Unless we pay him off we're stuck with him next season. Terrible touch, poor player

Jay Simpson - 6 - You can see his intelligence on the ball but was never fit enough to make a contribution. Can't imagine a L1 team would offer him a contract and with a pre-season behind him you never know

Done

What did Alabi do to warrant a 5 ? genuine question?

[jamespevans]

These ratings are far more accurate than the opening posts ( IMO of course)

Very similar views though, one persons 2 is anothers 5.