Judd or Ling v Salford

[CreamofSumYungGai]

Ling for me. I thought last season he was a liability, but he has started well this season. Of course he can't cross, but as a full back, he deserves the spot.

Where was Judd for Crawley's third goal? The facto that Palmer was completely unmarked was probably Ekpiteta's fault in the main, but I don't think Judd was anywhere near.

You're blaming Judd even though you acknowledge it was Ekpiteta's mistake?

Another in the queue for the Ling gloryhole.

I'm simply saying that he was no where near and as a right back, I would have expected him to be.

Good point, he should have left his man unmarked on the penalty spot and gone back out wide to the right back berth.

[CreamofSumYungGai]

I am removing Bob's vote as null and void given his above assessment. He doesn't deserve the vote.

[Red_Army]

Ling for me. I thought last season he was a liability, but he has started well this season. Of course he can't cross, but as a full back, he deserves the spot.

Where was Judd for Crawley's third goal? The facto that Palmer was completely unmarked was probably Ekpiteta's fault in the main, but I don't think Judd was anywhere near.

Have you even seen their 3rd goal?

Judd is inside of Marvin marking his own man. I love Marv but that goal was his fault all day long, first with that p*ss poor clearance then letting Palmer drift off the back of him.

Agree Marv should have done better , he doesn't seem to be the same player this season

I've watched it back. I really don't want this to be come a Ling vs Judd situation, but if people are going to pick up what they believe to be tiny errors by Ling, then I've got to ask why Judd decided to follow the winger all the way inside when he ad no hope of catching him, and he had moved across towards Coulson. No way should Judd have ended up inside Marvin there.

[bobo66]

Ling for me. I thought last season he was a liability, but he has started well this season. Of course he can't cross, but as a full back, he deserves the spot.

Where was Judd for Crawley's third goal? The facto that Palmer was completely unmarked was probably Ekpiteta's fault in the main, but I don't think Judd was anywhere near.

Have you even seen their 3rd goal?

Judd is inside of Marvin marking his own man. I love Marv but that goal was his fault all day long, first with that p*ss poor clearance then letting Palmer drift off the back of him.

I only saw it on the day, perhaps I need to watch the highlights, but have not been able to bring myself to do so. I usually only watch them when we win.

[CreamofSumYungGai]

Have you even seen their 3rd goal?

Judd is inside of Marvin marking his own man. I love Marv but that goal was his fault all day long, first with that p*ss poor clearance then letting Palmer drift off the back of him.

Agree Marv should have done better , he doesn't seem to be the same player this season

I've watched it back. I really don't want this to be come a Ling vs Judd situation, but if people are going to pick up what they believe to be tiny errors by Ling, then I've got to ask why Judd decided to follow the winger all the way inside when he ad no hope of catching him, and he had moved across towards Coulson. No way should Judd have ended up inside Marvin there.

Absolute WUM.

Coulson is covering the left back spot and the near post. Possibly slightly too far beyond the near post but guess he needs to make sure he can attack the player with the ball if needed.

Judd tracks the runner with the ball as he of course should do. After their bloke plays it out wide, he stays with that man. Anyone suggesting he should do anything else if on a WUM. I would argue Judd is possibly too deep and a short ball back to his man would have caught him out, but that's a different argument.

[CreamofSumYungGai]

Ling for me. I thought last season he was a liability, but he has started well this season. Of course he can't cross, but as a full back, he deserves the spot.

Where was Judd for Crawley's third goal? The facto that Palmer was completely unmarked was probably Ekpiteta's fault in the main, but I don't think Judd was anywhere near.

Have you even seen their 3rd goal?

Judd is inside of Marvin marking his own man. I love Marv but that goal was his fault all day long, first with that p*ss poor clearance then letting Palmer drift off the back of him.

I only saw it on the day, perhaps I need to watch the highlights, but have not been able to bring myself to do so. I usually only watch them when we win.

Fair enough mate.

Take it that's you changing your vote to Judd, if so I'll reinstate you.

[Smendrick Feaselberg]

POLL UPDATE

Judd - 2 (CoSYG, BM)

Son of DOF - 3 (SF, OP, DB) B66 right to vote removed

Turley - 3 (AW, L7, Ron)

Red Army - I'm not sure if you're serious or not with that comment?

Why are we counting Turley when the poll was Ling or Judd and Turley hasn't played a game yet this season?

[Red_Army]

Agree Marv should have done better , he doesn't seem to be the same player this season

I've watched it back. I really don't want this to be come a Ling vs Judd situation, but if people are going to pick up what they believe to be tiny errors by Ling, then I've got to ask why Judd decided to follow the winger all the way inside when he ad no hope of catching him, and he had moved across towards Coulson. No way should Judd have ended up inside Marvin there.

Absolute WUM.

Coulson is covering the left back spot and the near post. Possibly slightly too far beyond the near post but guess he needs to make sure he can attack the player with the ball if needed.

Judd tracks the runner with the ball as he of course should do. After their bloke plays it out wide, he stays with that man. Anyone suggesting he should do anything else if on a WUM. I would argue Judd is possibly too deep and a short ball back to his man would have caught him out, but that's a different argument.

What are you talking about- Coulson is playing left-sided centre back. He doesn't track his runner, he slots into Marvin's position as Marvin has had to chase Palmer into the vacant right back position. Anyway, it would all be academic if the 30 had been shown the line and wasn't allowed to drive into the centre of the field past Judd.

[Rich Tea Wellin]

Turley when fit should start in my opinion , if Ling would cross more it would improve him 100% , hard to choose between him and Judd

This makes for interesting reading-

Crosses or successful crosses?

[Red_Army]

Turley when fit should start in my opinion , if Ling would cross more it would improve him 100% , hard to choose between him and Judd

This makes for interesting reading-

Crosses or successful crosses?

Crosses, and that is a fair point. That said, We have only scored two goals that has come from a cross this season, and one was by Ling. There was a cross against Stevenage from Ling that Wilkinson should probably have scored from too.

[bobo66]

Have you even seen their 3rd goal?

Judd is inside of Marvin marking his own man. I love Marv but that goal was his fault all day long, first with that p*ss poor clearance then letting Palmer drift off the back of him.

I only saw it on the day, perhaps I need to watch the highlights, but have not been able to bring myself to do so. I usually only watch them when we win.

Fair enough mate.

Take it that's you changing your vote to Judd, if so I'll reinstate you.

No, I still vote for Ling ahead of Judd. Although you probably won't accept this view.

[CreamofSumYungGai]

I've watched it back. I really don't want this to be come a Ling vs Judd situation, but if people are going to pick up what they believe to be tiny errors by Ling, then I've got to ask why Judd decided to follow the winger all the way inside when he ad no hope of catching him, and he had moved across towards Coulson. No way should Judd have ended up inside Marvin there.

Absolute WUM.

Coulson is covering the left back spot and the near post. Possibly slightly too far beyond the near post but guess he needs to make sure he can attack the player with the ball if needed.

Judd tracks the runner with the ball as he of course should do. After their bloke plays it out wide, he stays with that man. Anyone suggesting he should do anything else if on a WUM. I would argue Judd is possibly too deep and a short ball back to his man would have caught him out, but that's a different argument.

What are you talking about- Coulson is playing left-sided centre back. He doesn't track his runner, he slots into Marvin's position as Marvin has had to chase Palmer into the vacant right back position. Anyway, it would all be academic if the 30 had been shown the line and wasn't allowed to drive into the centre of the field past Judd.

Not biting anymore

[CreamofSumYungGai]

Turley when fit should start in my opinion , if Ling would cross more it would improve him 100% , hard to choose between him and Judd

This makes for interesting reading-

Crosses or successful crosses?

Are they including throw ins?

[redintheface]

Marsh.

[O my gawd]

Judd should, Ling will.

Ling will, Ling should

[BiggsyMalone]

Judd should, Ling will.

Ling will, Ling should

Another one for the the Ling gloryhole

[Wally Banter]

Another one for the the Ling gloryhole

Be careful: in all likelihood, he'll trap the ball very awkwardly, shrink a bit, and then come inside.

[jamespevans]

Add me to the Judd should but won't start list

[Howling Mad Murdock]

Both.

[CreamofSumYungGai]

Both.

I have to accept your first answer, so assuming you gave them alphabetically means Judd.

[Red_Army]

What has Judd done to take the shirt from Ling? If fit, Ling should and will start.

[CreamofSumYungGai]

Played better than Sam.

[F*ck The Poor & Fat]

Non question. If fit, Ling will start. We all know that. Blue-eyed boy that he is.

First name on the team sheet.

[Red_Army]

Played better than Sam.

This season? You're having me on...

[Howling Mad Murdock]

The board was so much better when we did proper polls.