Admin wrote: ↑Mon May 20, 2024 7:04 pm
Think I've said this already - I'm no fan of Israel's actions (nor Hamas before anyone asks) but Nazi comparisons are offensive and add nothing.
Posts deleted for the moment. Repeat offenders will face a ban.
Wow.... You didn't strike me as a man that would silence debate and reduce democracy
Admin wrote: ↑Mon May 20, 2024 7:04 pm
Think I've said this already - I'm no fan of Israel's actions (nor Hamas before anyone asks) but Nazi comparisons are offensive and add nothing.
Posts deleted for the moment. Repeat offenders will face a ban.
Wow.... You didn't strike me as a man that would silence debate and reduce democracy
He's right though, comparing the genocidal actions of the Israeli state with the Nazis is offensive.
It would be more useful to point out that Zionist ideology elevates one race/religion beyond all others and that is a hallmark of fascism.
Never forget, fascism doesn't start with the concentration camps. That's where it ends.
Admin wrote: ↑Mon May 20, 2024 7:04 pm
Think I've said this already - I'm no fan of Israel's actions (nor Hamas before anyone asks) but Nazi comparisons are offensive and add nothing.
Posts deleted for the moment. Repeat offenders will face a ban.
Wow.... You didn't strike me as a man that would silence debate and reduce democracy
He's right though, comparing the genocidal actions of the Israeli state with the Nazis is offensive.
It would be more useful to point out that Zionist ideology elevates one race/religion beyond all others and that is a hallmark of fascism.
Never forget, fascism doesn't start with the concentration camps. That's where it ends.
I agree with your last 2 paragraphs, but only Israel would get the protection Admin has afforded it
If I were to call the Russians the N word, I guarantee that would be acceptable.
Remember the old Voltaire saying " to find out who rules over you, find out who you're not allowed to criticize". Or words to that effect
Admin wrote: ↑Mon May 20, 2024 7:04 pm
Think I've said this already - I'm no fan of Israel's actions (nor Hamas before anyone asks) but Nazi comparisons are offensive and add nothing.
Posts deleted for the moment. Repeat offenders will face a ban.
Wow.... You didn't strike me as a man that would silence debate and reduce democracy
I’ve done neither. I’ve asked that offensive comparisons aren’t used. Neither post removed added anything to any debate.
Anti Semitic content wasn't removed, anti Israel content was removed.
Ones a religion, the others a nation.
Please get your terminology correct before you make silly posts
Anti Semitic content wasn't removed, anti Israel content was removed.
Ones a religion, the others a nation.
Please get your terminology correct before you make silly posts
The IHRA working definition of antisemitism begs to differ
In other news, maybe reflect on the fact you’re quoting neo nazis
Last edited by Currywurst and Chips on Mon May 20, 2024 10:23 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Anti Semitic content wasn't removed, anti Israel content was removed.
Ones a religion, the others a nation.
Please get your terminology correct before you make silly posts
Go read the IHRA definitions of anti-semitism.
Quote from it: Drawing comparisons of contemporary Israeli policy to that of the Nazis.
I’d stop now as you’re making yourself look a bit silly (again). I understand it’s an emotive subject and I’m no supporter of Israel’s actions but I’m not resorting to using anti-Semitic tropes to express my view.
The guy that drew up the IHRA definition of anti-Semitism, wasn't happy with it, and disowned it.
I have the article somewhere.
When I find it I'll post it
It confuses anti Semitism with anti Zionism
1400 Jewish American professors have petitioned for it to be removed for that very reason
I'll post a lot of stuff that discredits the IHRA definition tomorrow when I find it
Anti Zionism is legal and allowed (except on this board it seems)
Anti Semitic content wasn't removed, anti Israel content was removed.
Ones a religion, the others a nation.
Please get your terminology correct before you make silly posts
Apart from Israel how many other nations in the world is Jewish .?
Anti Semitic content wasn't removed, anti Israel content was removed.
Ones a religion, the others a nation.
Please get your terminology correct before you make silly posts
Apart from Israel how many other nations in the world is Jewish .?
Anti Semitic content wasn't removed, anti Israel content was removed.
Ones a religion, the others a nation.
Please get your terminology correct before you make silly posts
Apart from Israel how many other nations in the world is Jewish .?
ComeOnYouOs wrote: ↑Mon May 20, 2024 10:41 pm
The guy that drew up the IHRA definition of anti-Semitism, wasn't happy with it, and disowned it.
I have the article somewhere.
When I find it I'll post it
It confuses anti Semitism with anti Zionism
1400 Jewish American professors have petitioned for it to be removed for that very reason
I'll post a lot of stuff that discredits the IHRA definition tomorrow when I find it
Anti Zionism is legal and allowed (except on this board it seems)
Ok, I said id post a lot of stuff that questions the Ihra definition of anti semitism, and the links below from all over the place, including Jewish authorities explain why that definition is flawed
Basically, the IHRA definition of antisemitism simply protects Israel from justified criticism, it stifles free speech
The links below explain it well