Do the very best footballers make the best managers?

[DrWindy]

His partnership with Dixon at Chelsea is still talked about. .

He can thank Dalglish for making him into that player.

It’s a wonderful quip, but it doesn’t work. If you knew your football you’d know that Speedie played with Dixon at Chelsea long before he was ever managed by Dalglish
.

[Hoover Attack]

Thank you for explaining my ‘joke’.

[DrWindy]

Thank you for explaining my ‘joke’.

The joke didn’t work though as it was factually incorrect. If you’re going to try and belittle fellow boarders and Orient fans then do better.

[Hoover Attack]

The factually incorrect bit is the joke.

Do I need to explain the joke?

[Give it to Jabo]

Depends what you call a Decent Player. I'd say Arteta,Guardiola were decent players.

Very decent players. Arguably not world-class.

[DrWindy]

The factually incorrect bit is the joke.

Do I need to explain the joke?

Yes please explain the joke. Or maybe just admit you made a mistake and move on. I wonder what option you are going to go with

[Hoover Attack]

The only mistake I made was getting drawn into your Dalglish is God nonsense.

[CEB]

This is painful

[DrWindy]

The only mistake I made was getting drawn into your Dalglish is God nonsense.

Again, absolute nonsense. I never said such a thing. You said he was a bad manager. I said it was harsh. After being unable to sensibly discuss the subject you now make up the suggestion I think he’s god. Utter rubbish. Grow up.

[Hoover Attack]

This is painful

Now you have the tiniest inkling of how we all feel.

[Adz]

The obvious one who comes to mind is pep, a couple of hundred games for barca, 50 caps for Spain, and his managerial record is well known. But the answer is no, there's as much chance of them being sh*t as any other ex pro

[CEB]

That’s the last time I stick up for you, Hoover attack

[B.whitehouse+10more]

Wayne Rooney proves beyond any doubt they don’t, Frank Lampard Jnr will second that.