Islas Malvinas

[The Mindsweep]

About time the correct name for the place is being recognised

[Oisin Hardy]

About time the correct name for the place is being recognised

Where is this it sounds like a Lidls red wine?

[Dunners]

The indigenous population of the islands seem to want the place to be called The Falkland Islands. But for some reason, some non-residents seem to think that the will of an imperialist colonial state located about 1,000 miles away, with a recent history of fascist military dictatorship and invasion tendencies, should take priority.

[The Mindsweep]

The indigenous population of the islands seem to want the place to be called The Falkland Islands. But for some reason, some non-residents seem to think that the will of an imperialist colonial state located about 1,000 miles away, with a recent history of fascist military dictatorship and invasion tendencies, should take priority.

I thought the only indigenous population were penguins? How have expressed their preference?

[Dunners]

The indigenous population of the islands seem to want the place to be called The Falkland Islands. But for some reason, some non-residents seem to think that the will of an imperialist colonial state located about 1,000 miles away, with a recent history of fascist military dictatorship and invasion tendencies, should take priority.

I thought the only indigenous population were penguins? How have expressed their preference?

Does that same principle apply to other land masses, such as Australia, or the entire continent of America?

[Proposition Joe]

Had never actually thought about it from that point of view, Dunners. I can't think of anywhere else where the present day international community (or at least, large parts of it) say to a population "stuff what you want, we're calling you this".

[BIGRON]

About time the correct name for the place is being recognised

Where is this it sounds like a Lidls red wine?

Some of Lidls red ain't bad

[Dunners]

To be fair, The Falklands is just another one of those things to which the British left go full-on crank mode. The default position often taken is to be sympathetic to the Argentinians.

And yet:

• There was no previous population displaced by the initial colonisers. The Islands were as empty as Australia was when the first peoples arrived.

• Prior to the war, the population expressed an overwhelming desire to remain a British territory.

• There was British political interest in a pragmatic solution of shared sovereignty of the islands with Argentina, possibly leading to full assignment should the population want that in the future (the UK government didn’t want the expense).

• But Argentina (which is itself a colonial project from when Iberian conquerors slaughtered the previous inhabitants and stole their lands – but let’s conveniently overlook that) decided to invade with a military force and occupy the islands against the wishes of the population.

• They did this to distract their own citizens from their oppression and political and financial incompetence, not because of any just cause.

• The British forces set sail, one thing led to another, and the Argentinians had their arses handed to them on a plate.

• Even the sinking of the Belgrano, which is often seized upon as an example of how awful Britain is, was confirmed as a legitimate target by its own Captain (but let's also conveniently overlook that).

• The Argentinian forces then f*cked off home and eventually the military dictatorship collapsed.

• The local population were liberated, and their resolve to remain British is now even firmer and any notion of shared sovereignty has now been pushed back for generations. All thanks to Argentina's reckless behavour.

• But Britain bad.

There’s plenty to criticise Britain about. But the Falklands just isn’t one of them.

[Max B Gold]

Point 1 is wrong. I didn't read any further. Where did you c&p it from?

[Dunners]

Point 1 is not wrong. There was no indigenous population before European settlers arrived in 1764.

[RedDwarf 1881]

About time the correct name for the place is being recognised

Wind up merchant .

[RedDwarf 1881]

We all know why this topic has sprung up it"s because the EU called the Falklands The Malvinas . Well British lives were lost defending the people who lived on those islands . If WW3 ever breaks out I hope the first nuke lands right on Brussels .

[Dunners]

A bit harsh RD. Next you'll be calling for the nuking of the French for using Londres instead of London.

[RedDwarf 1881]

A bit harsh RD. Next you'll be calling for the nuking of the French for using Londres instead of London.

Not harsh at all and anyway the example you gave is different from Falklands situation . Fair enough , I haven't liked the EU for many years but because of their attitude towards us since 2016 I now feel I'm beginning to hate them .

[Orient_Man_And_Boy]

A bit harsh RD. Next you'll be calling for the nuking of the French for using Londres instead of London.

The French have never forgiven us for being awarded the Prime Meridian - Greenwich rather than Paris (rhymes with Arris ).

[Scuba Diver]

We all know why this topic has sprung up it"s because the EU called the Falklands The Malvinas . Well British lives were lost defending the people who lived on those islands . If WW3 ever breaks out I hope the first nuke lands right on Brussels .

One of the strangest organisations to ever exist. Widely known they don't even know how many people work for it. The epitome of snouts in the trough no doubt.

Back to the topic, in 2014, the (human) residents (not the penguins, for the avoidance of doubt for some on here) voted in a census of 99.8% to 0.2% in favour of staying alligned with the UK.
The Scottish Independence/Brexit vote it was not.

Unless some are insisting that Argentian alignment is forced on the 99.8% for some weird reason, surely that ends the matter.

[EastDerehamO]

Back to the original post, so should we start calling Germany "Deutschland" etc etc from now on too?!

[Lost not Found]

I've spoken to the chief of staff for the penguin regiment and he says that he is rather fond of tea and British cheese so definitely identified as British as well.

f9ef76177f03b794feb40f1bcc7e6d07.jpg (55.36 KiB) Viewed 958 times

The EU are on a wind up and the usual gammons have fallen for it. Their reticence in any response to Russia rolling up to their own doorstep suggests they're unlikely to be getting involved in any shenanigans in the southern hemisphere so hardly any need to worry.

I wonder if there's any domestic issues at home the Argentinans want to distract from? While also providing some red meat for our rather sub standard government to try and posture over.

[spen666]

Had never actually thought about it from that point of view, Dunners. I can't think of anywhere else where the present day international community (or at least, large parts of it) say to a population "stuff what you want, we're calling you this".

Gibraltar?

[Lost not Found]

Back to the original post, so should we start calling Germany "Deutschland" etc etc from now on too?!

Which bit?

Modern Germany is pre dated by the the Falklands. whenever people want to rewrite borders it's always good to ask them exactly what year everything was perfect.

[Proposition Joe]

Had never actually thought about it from that point of view, Dunners. I can't think of anywhere else where the present day international community (or at least, large parts of it) say to a population "stuff what you want, we're calling you this".

Gibraltar?

What do the locals want to be called instead of Gibraltar?

[The Mindsweep]

I've spoken to the chief of staff for the penguin regiment and he says that he is rather fond of tea and British cheese so definitely identified as British as well.

f9ef76177f03b794feb40f1bcc7e6d07.jpg

The EU are on a wind up and the usual gammons have fallen for it. Their reticence in any response to Russia rolling up to their own doorstep suggests they're unlikely to be getting involved in any shenanigans in the southern hemisphere so hardly any need to worry.

I wonder if there's any domestic issues at home the Argentinans want to distract from? While also providing some red meat for our rather sub standard government to try and posture over.

Pingüino or pingüina please, not penguin

[Scuba Diver]

The EU are on a wind up

Ah it's just a WUM. You'd have thought they'd have more important things to concern themselves with, but clearly not.
The long winter evenings must fly by in Bruxelles that's for sure.
Perhaps the Mods can get Ursula von der Leyen onto the MB as she's so up for a high quality WUM like this very one.

[Frogger]

Once we have sucked out the 10 billion gallons of oils from underneath the island, the Argies can have it back.

[Monkey Boy]

About time the correct name for the place is being recognised

Once again a disrespectful post on here to stir up the sh-t. Perhaps you should ask all the widows, service men that were injured in the conflict, I know drop Simon Western a text and tell him your views. Sort of post that tuffers or one of his close numptys would put on there