Here is Rule
5.2.2 any requirements or directions of the UK Government and/or by any public authority,
the fixture shall be abandoned, each Club shall bear its own costs and neither Club shall progress to the next round. Where this results in an uneven number of Clubs being entered into the next round, the Management Committee shall arrange for byes where necessary.
Try not quoting things edited and out of context to make it seem like it is something different to what it is
....
What has 5.2.2 got to do with anything. That rule applies where BOTH sides are unable to fulfill the fixture because BOTH sides have players testing positive
.2 If both Clubs are unable to fulfil their obligation to complete a Competition match in Round One to (and including) Round Four due to either:
5.2.1 both Club’s Player(s) having returned a positive CAT result and self-isolating in accordance with the action plan set out in the Return to Play/Return to Training Protocols resulting in both Clubs not having a sufficient number of Players to fulfil the fixture; or
5.2.2 any requirements or directions of the UK Government and/or by any public authority,
the fixture shall be abandoned, each Club shall bear its own costs and neither Club shall progress to the next round. Where this results in an uneven number of Clubs being entered into the next round, the Management Committee shall arrange for byes where necessary.
It seems we were able to field a team for the match as Nigel said. PHE did not fail or close the ground the EFL stopped the game going ahead.
We as a club in being fair and co-operative have been punished by the EFL, whereas if we had stood by their chaotic and non excistent testing procedures (i dont think there is any) then we would have gone ahead and played the match, as other's from the EFL did.
If they tested every EFL club with the same tests we undertook before this weekend programme of league fixtures, i would doubt there would be many games as most clubs would fail.
On a purely financial standpoint maybe we were naive.
PutneyO wrote: ↑Thu Sep 24, 2020 11:36 am
The match should go ahead after the agreed period of self isolation (10 days?). If the EFL object to this it will prove what we know already and that is that they are a vindictive bunch oh sh1ts.
More or less impossible as midweek in a fortnight's time is for international games and Spurs will have players involved. If Spurs go through to group stages of Europa League, there are no midweeks available for the rest of the year. And also Chelsea have no midweeks available thanks to Champions League. Also UEFA don't like domestic games involving top level teams taking place when their games are on. Probably nothing EFL can do.
PutneyO wrote: ↑Thu Sep 24, 2020 11:36 am
The match should go ahead after the agreed period of self isolation (10 days?). If the EFL object to this it will prove what we know already and that is that they are a vindictive bunch oh sh1ts.
More or less impossible as midweek in a fortnight's time is for international games and Spurs will have players involved. If Spurs go through to group stages of Europa League, there are no midweeks available for the rest of the year. And also Chelsea have no midweeks available thanks to Champions League. Also UEFA don't like domestic games involving top level teams taking place when their games are on. Probably nothing EFL can do.
PutneyO wrote: ↑Thu Sep 24, 2020 11:36 am
The match should go ahead after the agreed period of self isolation (10 days?). If the EFL object to this it will prove what we know already and that is that they are a vindictive bunch oh sh1ts.
More or less impossible as midweek in a fortnight's time is for international games and Spurs will have players involved. If Spurs go through to group stages of Europa League, there are no midweeks available for the rest of the year. And also Chelsea have no midweeks available thanks to Champions League. Also UEFA don't like domestic games involving top level teams taking place when their games are on. Probably nothing EFL can do.
That changed a couple of years ago I believe, so it could be done but there's no space in the calender for it I don't think. It would need Spurs and Chelsea to agree.
I couldn’t care less about the tinpot cup. I just want all the sufferers to get better soon and somebody to give us the same money as Sky were going to pay us. Maybe a cash transfer from Spurs or maybe a big brown bag from the EFL.
DuvB wrote: ↑Thu Sep 24, 2020 5:45 pm
I couldn’t care less about the tinpot cup. I just want all the sufferers to get better soon and somebody to give us the same money as Sky were going to pay us. Maybe a cash transfer from Spurs or maybe a big brown bag from the EFL.
Why should Spurs Pay us?
Our medical team have been totally inept!
DuvB wrote: ↑Thu Sep 24, 2020 5:45 pm
I couldn’t care less about the tinpot cup. I just want all the sufferers to get better soon and somebody to give us the same money as Sky were going to pay us. Maybe a cash transfer from Spurs or maybe a big brown bag from the EFL.
Why should Spurs Pay us?
Our medical team have been totally inept!
Not sure there is any evidence to support your claim re medical team. Anyone can catch Covid
Prestige Worldwide wrote: ↑Thu Sep 24, 2020 7:07 pm
Why would the club have a fictitious team ready to play?
The whole point is they didn't have a team to play
You've got this backwards.
So what would they have done if they were permitted to play?
More credible that they had an XI who would have undoubtably lost but secured the TV money. They don't want to play this XI in the league and squander 3 points. Although they stupidly are risking a points deduction.
Prestige Worldwide wrote: ↑Thu Sep 24, 2020 7:07 pm
Why would the club have a fictitious team ready to play?
The whole point is they didn't have a team to play
You've got this backwards.
So what would they have done if they were permitted to play?
More credible that they had an XI who would have undoubtably lost but secured the TV money. They don't want to play this XI in the league and squander 3 points. Although they stupidly are risking a points deduction.
The whole point is they didn't have a team to play
You've got this backwards.
So what would they have done if they were permitted to play?
More credible that they had an XI who would have undoubtably lost but secured the TV money. They don't want to play this XI in the league and squander 3 points. Although they stupidly are risking a points deduction.
Money over safety then
Which is how we ended up in this situation - Ling (and to a lesser extent Macklin) have executive power to intervene if it looks like ignoring the safety imperative will actually further risk the financial situation, but neither of them had the wit or vision to see that risk. Ling was just simply asleep at the wheel. We'll get censured for this, and rightly so. The financial implications won't be good either. Short-termism costs, every time.
So what would they have done if they were permitted to play?
More credible that they had an XI who would have undoubtably lost but secured the TV money. They don't want to play this XI in the league and squander 3 points. Although they stupidly are risking a points deduction.
Money over safety then
Which is how we ended up in this situation - Ling (and to a lesser extent Macklin) have executive power to intervene if it looks like ignoring the safety imperative will actually further risk the financial situation, but neither of them had the wit or vision to see that risk. Ling was just simply asleep at the wheel. We'll get censured for this, and rightly so. The financial implications won't be good either. Short-termism costs, every time.
DuvB wrote: ↑Thu Sep 24, 2020 5:45 pm
I couldn’t care less about the tinpot cup. I just want all the sufferers to get better soon and somebody to give us the same money as Sky were going to pay us. Maybe a cash transfer from Spurs or maybe a big brown bag from the EFL.
Why should Spurs Pay us?
Our medical team have been totally inept!
Not sure there is any evidence to support your claim re medical team. Anyone can catch Covid
Although a number of people were showing symptoms the medical staff didn’t pick up on these apparently.