Crowd sounds on Match Stream?

[EliotNes]

A question for anyone who watched the stream, "Were there any crowd sounds such as we hear on the current Sky/BBC/BT TV streams?"

[Real Al]

No.

It was so quiet people were complaining they could hear Dave's phone pinging

[Clive Evans]

Every crowd sounding like Aldershot.

[EliotNes]

Every crowd sounding like Aldershot.

Thanks

[Ronnie Hotdogs]

No fake sound on Oldhams iFollow feedeither.

[KC & sunshine band]

It was a strange noise like someone climbing up and down a ladder

[RedDwarf 1881]

Talking about crowds , I'm currently watching a ligue 1 game from France . They have a well spread out crowd in attendance. It's irritating that we can't do the same in this country.

[Clive Evans]

Talking about crowds , I'm currently watching a ligue 1 game from France . They have a well spread out crowd in attendance. It's irritating that we can't do the same in this country............................................Yeah we need to accelerate the spread of Covid 19 a bit faster. Too many Oldies like me are still living.

[PutneyO]

Those artificial crowd sounds are insulting and patronising.

[gshaw]

Those artificial crowd sounds are insulting and patronising.

I prefer it to silence tbh. That said for home games it'll be no different to usual being able to hear a pin drop

[ComeOnYouOs]

I prefer the artificial crowd noise. It makes for more of an atmosphere

[RedDwarf 1881]

Talking about crowds , I'm currently watching a ligue 1 game from France . They have a well spread out crowd in attendance. It's irritating that we can't do the same in this country............................................Yeah we need to accelerate the spread of Covid 19 a bit faster. Too many Oldies like me are still living.

So the French have got it wrong then . Fair enough .

[RedDwarf 1881]

I prefer the artificial crowd noise. It makes for more of an atmosphere

I agree . Watching the Oldham V Orient highlights sounded like it was a training game over at Hackney Marshes.

[Highwood Man]

It looked a bit like that at times too.

[A Pedant]

I find the fake crowd noise akin to the uncanny valley in robotics, it's trying to be real but in being not quite right it becomes unnerving. Because I know that the noise is being generated by a human sat at a mixing desk, it just feels wrong - particularly when it diverts from what would really happen (there's no booing the home team when they're playing badly, nor the gradual quietening as people slope off when losing 0-2 with 10 mins to go, nor abuse shouted at the ref after a contentious decision etc.).

Give me the real ground noise every time.

[Disoriented]

Would be good to hear recorded sounds from the South Stand. I miss the quality fair-minded and intelligent comments which come from there.

[3GO]

Please no fake crowd noise, the noise on Sky and BT is dire. My only problem with Dulcet's phone pinging is I keep thinking it's my phone. The solution really is for DD to concentrate on commentating on the play. The texts and tweets could go and not be missed IMO

[StillSpike]

Obviously real crowd noise from a real crowd is best.

That said, if we have to have no crowd in the ground, then I do think all sports coverage benefits from the "fake" noise, otherwise you're just listening to the players shouting at each other in a big echo-ey stadium, and that's awful for me. I think the only reason the "fake" noise is annoying is that we know it's "fake".

I quite like the fake noise put on the Test matches - that sort of murmmering you get in a cricket ground that gets a bit louder during the day as the pints go down.

[EliotNes]

I wonder if Sky will be dubbing (or whatever they do) crowd sounds for the match vs Spurs on Tuesday.

[Real Al]

I wonder if Sky will be dubbing (or whatever they do) crowd sounds for the match vs Spurs on Tuesday.

They've probably only got Champions League noises, which will be odd.

[Ronnie Hotdogs]

I wonder if Sky will be dubbing (or whatever they do) crowd sounds for the match vs Spurs on Tuesday.

If there’s as many in as yesterday, they won’t need to.

[tuffers#1]

Can we not have individual things for players.

Benny Hill music for Ruel maybe or
Chopin's Piano Sonata No. 2 in B-flat minor for Myles Judd ,
Nessum Dorma for DJ

[Fellowo]

Stream needs some crowd noise, in fact I found it boring watching us play in silence. Even once there was commentary that only improved it slightly.

Have to say that I'm not used to watching Orient via a stream and found it hard work.

[Rich Tea Wellin]

Stream needs some crowd noise, in fact I found it boring watching us play in silence. Even once there was commentary that only improved it slightly.

Have to say that I'm not used to watching Orient via a stream and found it hard work.

Yeah it wasn’t a particularly enjoyable experience. Made me feel like I was there.

[Real Al]

Can we not have individual things for players.

Benny Hill music for Ruel maybe or
Chopin's Piano Sonata No. 2 in B-flat minor for Myles Judd ,
Nessum Dorma for DJ

Oops, I did it again, for Craig Clay