Bandoff - Round of 16 - Tie 5

[StillSpike]

Please vote for your favourite
You may vote for 1 from the list
Polls open till tomorrow lunchtime

Please feel free to post about why you've selected your favourite - you may be able to persuade fellow boarders with youtubes, tracks, anecdotes or simple bribery.

[Constanza]

Never liked the Floyd and I luv Your Song so its Elton for me

[Griffin1975]

This is the most difficult tie to date for me. After much deliberating, musing, cogitating, ruminating etc I have decided. It has to be Pink Floyd or perhaps....

[Thor]

Wow how can that many people have voted for Elton over one of the greatest bands of all time?

[Disoriented]

Elton John is not a band.

Nuff said.

[Thor]

But it's open to solo artists as well, but i agree the floyd are the winners here.

[Max B Gold]

Never been a Floyd fan but have been listening to a bit of them over lock down to see if I'm missing anything. I'm not. But I voted for them over Elton.

[slacker]

Elton’s got a cracking back catalogue of hits, but I can’t think of one LP I’d want to listen right through. Floyd started interesting as Syd Barrett’s psychedelia band, and got even better by the mid-70s with 2 superb albums, before tailing off, so they get the nod.